4938 Shares

Would things be different in America if.?

Would things be different in America if.? Topic: Would things be different in America if.?
July 19, 2019 / By Ursula
Question: The excellent film Amazing Grace shows how slavery throughout the British Empire was peacefully abolished in 1807 through the tireless efforts of William Wilberforce over a period of 20 years. We all know that it continued for much longer in America, and ultimately required a civil war to bring about its end. Had it not, do you think race relations in America would be vastly improved, i.e., more like what they are today in the UK?
Best Answer

Best Answers: Would things be different in America if.?

Scheherazade Scheherazade | 5 days ago
It isn't slavery per se that's made ethnic (race doesn't exist)relations what they are today. If whites had simply enslaved Africans and then Negroes, and then after slavery allowed them to access any occupation they had the skills for, there would be no problems. However, instead whites created something called "race," which held that one group was superior or inferior to the other. Some of the ways they "proved" this was through the use of pseudo-scientific fraud, such as craniometry, neoteny, or recapitulation. Another major white out was the exclusion of the accomplishments and contributions that Africans and Blacks have made to both the U.S. and the world. By not being able to read about Black inventors, etc., whites simply thought that "they didn't do anything to contribute to the building of the US." Even today, Blacks are more likely to appear in the media, which includes textbooks, in a few, stereotypical roles: athletes, welfare recipients, drug addicts, menial labor, etc., rather than as executives, supervisors, doctors, engineers, etc. During the past year and even now....Black entrepreneurs are the fastest growing group of business owners...but how many whites know that? Do you see that on CNN, CBS, NBC, FOX, or ABC?! Nope! But you do see plenty of criminals, don't you? Same old racist exclusion that whites were practicing 300 years ago....when they proclaimed that Africans were inferior, etc. See "Race: The Power of An Illusion": The division of the world's peoples into distinct groups - "red," "black," "white" or "yellow" peoples - has became so deeply imbedded in our psyches, so widely accepted, many would promptly dismiss as crazy any suggestion of its falsity. Yet, that's exactly what this provocative, new three-hour series by California Newsreel claims. Race - The Power of an Illusion questions the very idea of race as biology, suggesting that a belief in race is no more sound than believing that the sun revolves around the earth. Yet race still matters. Just because race doesn't exist in biology doesn't mean it isn't very real, helping shape life chances and opportunities. Episode 1- The Difference Between Us examines the contemporary science - including genetics - that challenges our common sense assumptions that human beings can be bundled into three or four fundamentally different groups according to their physical traits. Episode 2- The Story We Tell uncovers the roots of the race concept in North America, the 19th century science that legitimated it, and how it came to be held so fiercely in the western imagination. The episode is an eye-opening tale of how race served to rationalize, even justify, American social inequalities as "natural." Episode 3- The House We Live In asks, If race is not biology, what is it? This episode uncovers how race resides not in nature but in politics, economics and culture. It reveals how our social institutions "make" race by disproportionately channeling resources, power, status and wealth to white people. By asking, What is this thing called 'race'?, a question so basic it is rarely asked, Race - The Power of an Illusion helps set the terms that any further discussion of race must first take into account. Ideal for human biology, anthropology, sociology, American history, American studies, and cultural studies. Episodes are also available individually on VHS cassette by clicking below! Episode 1- The Difference Between Us Episode 2- The Story We Tell Episode 3- The House We Live In LINKS Press Release and Detailed Descriptions The Companion Website With lesson plans, interactivities and a wealth of educational content (at www.pbs.org/race) RESOURCES 10 Things Everyone Should Know About Race The Race Literacy Quiz Discussion Guide Toolkit (Adobe PDF, File Size 522KB) Race and Gene Studies: What Difference Makes a Difference?
👍 278 | 👎 5
Did you like the answer? Would things be different in America if.? Share with your friends
Scheherazade Originally Answered: Why is Roman history emphasized in America when Persia did the same things first?
Because Rome had more of an influence over western Europe than Persia did. Architecture, law, language, religion, and more derive from Rome, not Persia. And American history is derived from European history, thus the emphasis on Rome. Given the limited time available to teach history in class, it's not surprising to see a "western" bias" in what gets emphasized. It's not like America is the only country to take a "self centered" view of the world and the past.

Nubia Nubia
Hmmmm. I don't think that would matter at all. I think some would still use it as a crutch. Our culture has allowed it. I'm tired of hearing how the African-Americans are not treated as equals to this day. If African-Americans apply themselves, work hard in school, and prove themselves like anyone else, they have the opportunity (like anyone else who wants to take it) to prosper and live a decent life. Many have done very well and are respected by all. Even African-American politicians, whether you believe in their cause or not are respected by a majority of people. (Colin Powell, Condoleeza Rice, Obama, etc.) There were (and still are, in many ways, though they may not carry the title "slave") more barbaric examples of slavery throughout the world than what happened in the US. And most of it included "white" people. Hitler tried to wipe out a race. Does this mean in Germany the relationship between Jews and the rest of the German population are still strained? The people in the USA who should be upset about racial relations are the Native Americans who were forced off their own land and put onto small patches of land. Those whose children were taken away, sent to "civilized schools", dressed in "civilized clothes" and forced to learn a "civilized language". TO THIS DAY, these people have not been allowed to reclaim their own lands. I see too many belly-aching about how things WERE and how badly THEY WERE treated even all the while it has been several generations. If they really want to make a statement, they should become something positive. I was widowed with small children, but refused to receive handouts from the government. I penny pinched and made something of myself. But for those who still want to hear it, here it is: It was a terrible terrible thing that the European immigrants and all who were involved in the slave trade did to the Africans. I for one am sorry that so many people had to go through something like that and so many of their families were torn apart. Take comfort in knowing that the whole nation was not in agreement with what happened and that is why a nation went to war to free the slaves. It wasn't a clash of colors, but a clash of two totally different cultures within a country. Those who were slave-free in the North and those who used the blood, sweat and tears for their own profit in the South. Now however, is your opportunity to become whatever you dream, and to be a living legacy to your ancestors who gave all. They deserve to have you show you can rise above it all. You can take the opportunity and run with it and help make the world a better place or you can choose to do nothing. But it is YOUR choice. No one is stopping you. And it could take A LOT of work. But nothing in this life is free.
👍 120 | 👎 4

Macy Macy
I think things would be about the same. Even now some people are still trying to justify slavery and some still think blacks are inferior. Those thoughts didn't come about just because of how slavery ended. I personally think the overall mentality of Americans compared to Europeans is ultimately what caused our country's race relations to be so bad. It was just easier to blame and hate blacks for things that went wrong rather than taking responsibility, and that way of thinking unfortunately continues today.
👍 116 | 👎 3

Kelsie Kelsie
^^^ You are on point with the justifying of slavery and they are always the first ones to bring it up too... Like the dude above you just apologizing for no good reason. People like him pay entirely too much attention the rhetoric of Al Sharpton and Jesse Jackson...as if they speak for all black peopel everywhere. Some black folks are so wrapped up in bitterness and anger that they cannot see all the progress which has taken place. They're hardwired to concentrate on the negative. Some white people just want to pretend **** out of existence. Like slavery and the continued persecution an entire race of people just never happened. Like we all just skipped off into the freaking sunset singing shiny happy people. I don't know how you can say that injustice doesn't exist. Hell Women STILL earn less than men. But we can't admit that these disparities exist between racial groups? Look at the Native Americans. Look at the Mexicans. I'm not very pc so I have no issue with taking notice of the obvious. ...I don't know what the hell some of you are talking about with this 'playing field is level' crap. According to whom? A white MALE (25-40)...? Appears to be the case. Playing field isn't level--but it doesn't matter. It won't be level. Black people were never meant to make it as a people in this country. Racism is alive and well but it doesn't even matter. It's almost irrelevant. It's simply NOT the barrier that it once was. Some black people have to let go if bitterness. Others have to buckle down and get it together. We have to concentrate on ourselves and our communities. It is happening as we speak and I am glad for it. Oh well...
👍 112 | 👎 2

Kelsie Originally Answered: What are motivations for Koreans, Japanese and Chinese to travel and tour North America (Canada & America)?
I know nothing of Korean, and little of Chinese travellers. However, it is my understanding that the Japanese do not take annual trips like many in North America would. They tend to save up, and then every 10 years or so, make an extravagant holiday, picking an exotic place and doing everything that can be done, and staying in top places while they do it. If you have travelled to any top tourist spot in Canada (Banff, Niagara Falls, etc.) you can see them, busily clicking away on their cameras, and on a schedule - they might visit a museum for 20 minutes, while I am there for 2-3 hours. I have seen this a lot. Another thing they like to do is see the Northern Lights. They have a believe that a child conceived under the Northern Lights is lucky. So, they come to the North (Yukon, and NWT in particular) to, ummmm, "do what's natural" when the Northern Lights are out. I suspect Canada and the US are picked because of the English language, which many Japanese know at least some of (I imagine the same for Korean and Chinese visitors), whereas Europe has many different languages. There are also places with high concentrations of Japanese tourists that have signs and such in Japanese. I have seen this in Prince Edward Island (they love Anne of Green Gables, apparently), and Banff, amongst other places.

If you have your own answer to the question Would things be different in America if.?, then you can write your own version, using the form below for an extended answer.